If you8217;re not a fan of eyeliners with a high-gloss finish, this eyeliner is perfect! It dries down to a semi-matte plus you don8217;t need to layer too much since it8217;s pigment-packed. Because of its ultra-fine xbrush end, you can control how thick or thin you want your liner to be. It lasts long and holds up pretty well against water, sweat, and tears. If you8217;re after the best waterproof eyeliner, then we think we might just have found your new holy grail. Benefit Cosmetics have been a go-to forever when it comes to makeup essentials, so it8217;s no surprise that one of their eyeliners would make our top ten. You don't have to spend a fortune to get Recommended website a black eyeliner that really lasts. Work quickly with this one, because once it sets you'll need an oily makeup remover to get it off.